Across the CRUniverse
A CSP Staff Report from 2014 Convenience Retailing University
Loyalty specialist reveals paths toward building customer engagement
The best marketing intentions can lead to negative consumer responses—even making people feel “creeped out”—which is what keeps many retailers from creating successful loyalty programs, according to one consultant.
Bryan Pearson, president and CEO of LoyaltyOne Inc., Toronto, provided several examples of how companies can use data to engage customers but ultimately have a negative reaction.
The problem stems from so many brands fighting for attention and trying to rise above the clutter. In their zeal to use data and reach out, companies fail to truly understand their customer, he said.
“It’s about engaging people in a different way,” Pearson said, “one that creates meaningful connections.”
Speaking before about 500 retailers, suppliers and industry attendees, Pearson focused on defining relevance and using data in ways that will elicit positive, passionate responses. To help the conference audience understand, he cited several cases he has encountered in which the use of customer data was confusing, off-putting and at, least in one case, downright enraging:
- A frequent-flier reward: In his example, he had achieved the noteworthy status of flying a million miles with a specific airline. Without his knowing the parcel was coming, he received a very sophisticated black box. In it was a number of things that seemed irrelevant, even embarrassing to him: a model airplane, tags that would identify him as spending way too much time traveling and then at the bottom of the box, almost buried, something that really meant something to him. That was lifetime “elite” status. “They buried the punchline,” he said.
- Online group discounts: An online retailer offered a digital group discount, and Pearson became a recipient of other available discounts. But because he signed up for the initial retailer’s service in a different state than where he actually lived, he received group discounts for the city he didn’t live in.
- Department store retailer: Pearson also told a story of a department store that wanted to connect with pregnant mothers. The effort went sour in one instance when a young teenager’s father noticed the mailing and was infuriated that the retailer would send such an e-mail. He did not know his daughter was pregnant.
Relevant outreaches connect with people where they live at the stage of life they’re in and also tie back to their actual interests, Pearson said. These efforts are meaningful and typically stir up customer enthusiasm.
One of his examples of a success story was an oil company that needed to renovate and close down several stores. Using points to reward customers for changing fueling sites while their regular locations were undergoing renovation, the program actually persuaded people to not only stay brand loyal but also actually spend more.
In closing, Pearson suggested that before any company can succeed with loyalty, it has to ask itself difficult questions about its internal organization and its willingness to break down silos and share information. Data flows through many parts of an organization and must be shared to develop the kind of relevance that the customer needs.
As a next step, he suggested companies “be transparent and reasonable with your customers. Use data to create value.” --Angel Abcede